Recipe Reviews

Reviews (20)

  • MelanieJade 23 Feb, 2011

    (contin.) I also didn't use any flour or cocoa to roll out the dough. Probably because I left out the 4 TBSP butter. My cooking cutter was smaller, and I baked for 5 mins. They turned out soft, moist, and super chocolaty!

  • MelanieJade 14 Feb, 2011

    These are so delicious! I didn't have solid chocolate, so I used the substitute on the back of the cocoa box for semi-sweet chocolate. I also can't remember if I added the extra 4 TBS of butter....oh well, they are so rich and delicious and were much easier than I expected. I didn't use parchment because I don't use disposable products for cooking. I rolled the dough right on the sheet pan, chilled in the fridge (wouldn't fit in the freezer)

  • TerryLinden 9 Feb, 2011

    I only got 25 cookies w/ a cookie cutter measuring 2-1/2" high by 3" across. Any smaller and they would have qualified for 100 calories snacks. Baked 'em for 8 minutes and they turned out A-W-E-S-O-M-E !

  • mykele 8 Feb, 2011

    Ladies, FREEZE not REFRIGERATE......is it so hard to follow plain and simple
    instructions. I see too often in various cookie recipes comments that some
    do not follow basic directions to begin with and then complain about the
    results or ingredients amounts. Many aeem to be experienced bakers/
    cooks and not in the kitchen for the first time. Common sense is a basic
    rule. mykele

  • glamour 6 Feb, 2011

    If you don't have room in your freezer then don't make these cookies. It's really about making something yummy with your family. Someone commented that she said to cut the cookies out 1/2" apart but she said to place them 1/2" apart on the cookie sheet to bake. Lighten up and enjoy! If the recipes here freak you out then don't look.

  • glamour 6 Feb, 2011

    Everyone should relax if they wont fit in your freezer than dont make them. Also, someone commented that she said to cut them out 1/2" apart but she tells you to place them 1/2" apart on the cookie sheet to bake them. We should have fun and bake with your family. If the recipes on this page freak you out then dont look at it or make them. These cookies are amazing!

  • Glittery_Me 19 Dec, 2010

    I just made these lovely cookies. ;) They turned out great,but I must admit I overbaked them a bit,I baked them about 12 mins,cause I didn't think they were baked enough. But they turned out just fine,a bit harder but still good. :) I also added some sugar cookies icing and they looked pretty cute. :) These were my first baked cookies ever. :D

  • Laurel3113 23 Feb, 2010

    These are good little cookies :) I rolled them out and left them in the fridge over night and then cut. True the reused scrap cookies aren't as pretty but who cares...they taste just as good. I didn't think these lacked sweetness.

  • chefette86 17 Feb, 2009

    gerharti- if you remove the excess dough from around the cutouts, it would be more convenient than cutting and transferring, however, making your cuts 1/2" apart wastes a lot of the dough. Cookies look prettier when you first roll out the dough, so try to get as many cookies as possible out of the rolled out dough, so you have fewer scraps to reroll. When you take away the excess as you had suggested, simply rearrange the cookies to be 1/2" apart.

  • gerhartl 16 Feb, 2009

    Piping on a smaller heart of frosting might add to the sweetness.

  • gerhartl 16 Feb, 2009

    I wonder if it would work to roll out and cut the cookies on the parchment paper and remove the "outsides" from around the cookies and place the parchment paper straight onto the cookie sheet to bake. Easier than transferring from paper to pan. Be sure to make your cuts 1/2" apart.

  • hppygyrl18 12 Feb, 2009

    Although it was inconveinet to rearrange the freezer, I thought the cookies came out nice. My husband thought they could be sweeter, but I though they were just right.

  • Syls 12 Feb, 2009

    I will make this cookie for Easter using a bunny cutter and dust with conf. sugar.
    Baker from Fl.

  • wolf2 12 Feb, 2009

    I totally agree. No real families have freezer room like that.

  • 1950cookielady 11 Feb, 2009

    After using a third generation heirloom cutout recipe, I won't even try this recipe because of step 3. Who wants to play chinese checkers in the refrigerator trying to make a cookie sheet fit in just to chill the dough. Cookie baking should be fun!

  • heidibell 11 Feb, 2009

    Okay, kids, this is not rocket science. You can put the dough on any flat surface.
    If the dough is stiff...cover with waxpaper and lay on a cutting board or cardboard. It's just so the dough gets firm enough to use the cutters on.

  • terrie-bear 11 Feb, 2009

    dogchow-- Use a pizza pan instead, it will work just as well. It will not fit as many cookies, but should fit in your fridge.

  • dogchow 11 Feb, 2009

    what if baking tray doesn't fit in the referigerator?

  • MissMolly4u 11 Feb, 2009

    They are delicious and so super cute! Deffinitely follow the tip to use parchment paper to roll them out because the dough is sticky and don't roll them out too thin! I froze the dough for about 10 mins which worked just fine. I put vday sprinkles on mine! so cute!

  • cherybaby 10 Feb, 2009

    I made this dough, has anybody tried these cookies? i will bake them tonight hope they taste good
    I am putting the royal icing on some and maybe stamping them with
    valentine stamps